Thanksgiving in the Hamptons
Thanksgiving in the Hamptons has a quiet magic to it. The crowds have thinned, the light turns golden by four in the afternoon, and the villages of the South and North Fork settle into their most authentic season. At Luxury Beach Getaway, we’ve been welcoming families to the East End for nearly twenty years, and the holiday weekend is one of our favorites to help guests plan.
This guide brings together our favorite restaurants for Thanksgiving dinner, the farms and markets we lean on for turkey and pies, the wineries pouring on the shoulder season, and the walks, beaches, and small‑town moments that make the weekend feel like ours alone.
Where to Enjoy Thanksgiving Dinner in the Hamptons
For guests who prefer to hand the kitchen off to someone else, the East End has some of the most refined holiday dining on Long Island. Reservations for Thanksgiving Day fill up quickly, so we recommend booking as soon as your travel plans are set (early October is not too soon).
The American Hotel
Few rooms in the Hamptons feel more like Thanksgiving than the American Hotel in Sag Harbor. Dark wood, white tablecloths, a legendary wine list, and a service style that regulars have loved for decades. Guests describe “exceptional service” and “delightful” holiday luncheons here. It’s the sort of place where a long, slow meal is the entire plan for the day.
- Rating: 4.4 stars (452+ reviews)
- Address: 45 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
- Website: theamericanhotel.com
- Local tip: Business‑casual dress is expected; the room rewards a little effort.
Find The American Hotel on Google Maps

1770 House Restaurant & Inn
Set inside a beautifully restored 18th‑century home on East Hampton’s Main Street, the 1770 House feels almost custom‑built for a Thanksgiving dinner. Low ceilings, candlelight, a small dining room, and a menu that leans into the season. Guests praise “impeccable” service and a room that is “warm, and full of” character.
- Rating: 4.6 stars (308+ reviews)
- Address: 143 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937
- Website: 1770house.com
- Good to know: The intimate downstairs Tavern is our pick for a quieter meal.
Find 1770 House on Google Maps

Bell & Anchor
A local favorite tucked along Noyack Road between Sag Harbor and Noyack, Bell & Anchor has a loyal following for a reason. It’s polished but never fussy, and the waterside setting gives the meal a proper East End feel. The 4.7 rating tells you what you need to know about consistency.
- Rating: 4.7 stars (297+ reviews)
- Address: 3253 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
- Website: bellandanchor.com
- Local tip: Ask about the seafood tower to start the table.
Find Bell & Anchor on Google Maps

Lulu Kitchen & Bar
Right on Main Street in Sag Harbor, Lulu leans Mediterranean with a wood‑fired oven at the heart of the room. The energy is more lively than the classic white‑tablecloth spots, which makes it a great fit for families with older kids or a group that wants a meal that carries into the evening.
- Rating: 4.2 stars (551+ reviews)
- Address: 126 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
- Website: lulusagharbor.com
- Good to know: The bar seats are among the best in town for a solo bite or a pre‑dinner drink.
Find Lulu Kitchen & Bar on Google Maps

East Hampton Grill
If your table includes kids or picky eaters, East Hampton Grill is a reliable, everyone‑wins choice. Think refined comfort classics, warm lighting, and a room that hums with locals and visitors year‑round. It’s our go‑to when the plan needs to be simple and delicious.
- Rating: 4.3 stars (509+ reviews)
- Address: 99 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937
- Website: easthamptongrill.com
- Local tip: The dessert menu is worth saving room for; the ice cream sundaes are legendary.
Find East Hampton Grill on Google Maps
The Palm East Hampton
For a proper steakhouse Thanksgiving, The Palm on East Hampton’s Main Street delivers. Dry‑aged steaks, jumbo lobster, classic sides, and the caricatured walls that regulars know by heart. It’s rich, unapologetic, and a nice change of pace from a traditional turkey meal.
- Rating: 4.4 stars (420+ reviews)
- Address: 94 Main St Suite 1800, East Hampton, NY 11937
- Website: thepalm.com/restaurants/east-hampton
- Good to know: Book a booth if you can, they’re the coziest seats in the room.

Where to Source Your Thanksgiving Feast
If you’d rather cook in the house, you’re in the right place. The East End is farm country, and Thanksgiving week is when the local farm stands and markets shine. A few of our favorites for turkeys, pies, and everything in between.
Round Swamp Farm
Round Swamp is a Hamptons institution. Multi‑generational, family‑run, and the source of much of what shows up on East End Thanksgiving tables. Their prepared foods program (think stuffing, sides, and pies) is exceptional, and pre‑orders open in early November. Guests who make the drive out call it “one of a kind” and love the “home‑cooked feel” of everything they make.
- Rating: 4.0 stars (136+ reviews)
- Address: 184 County Rd 40, East Hampton, NY 11937
- Locations: East Hampton, Bridgehampton, and Montauk
- Website: roundswampfarm.com
- Local tip: Pre‑order by mid‑November for turkey and prepared sides. The Thanksgiving week schedule is limited, and Thanksgiving Day itself is closed.
Find Round Swamp Farm on Google Maps

Share the Harvest Farm
A small, community‑minded working farm on Long Lane in East Hampton, Share the Harvest is where we send guests who want ultra‑fresh vegetables, herbs, and eggs for a from‑scratch Thanksgiving. Their farm store carries beautiful seasonal produce, and every dollar spent supports their food‑access mission, a nice bonus at this time of year.
- Rating: 4.6 stars (17+ reviews)
- Address: 55 Long Lane, East Hampton, NY 11937
- Website: sharetheharvestfarm.org
- Good to know: Keep an eye on their site for a Thanksgiving Market at St. Luke’s Episcopal Church in East Hampton on the Saturday before the holiday.
Find Share the Harvest Farm on Google Maps

💡 Local tip: For turkeys, order from a farm no later than the first week of November. The good birds go fast, and Thanksgiving week pickup windows are tight.
How to Plan a Thanksgiving Getaway on the East End
A few things we’ve learned from twenty years of hosting families on the East End over the holiday:
- Travel Wednesday, not Thursday. Wednesday of Thanksgiving is one of the busiest travel days in the country. Come out Tuesday if you can, or first thing Wednesday morning, and you’ll save yourself hours in traffic on the LIE.
- Book restaurants in October. Every Thanksgiving room on this list is fully booked weeks in advance. If you plan on dining out, get on the reservation books early.
- Order the turkey by early November. Local farms sell out. The alternative is a supermarket bird, and once you’ve had a Round Swamp or Iacono Farm turkey, that’s a hard step down.
- Pack layers. Late November on the East End can swing from 55 degrees and sunny to 35 and windy in one afternoon.
- Plan one “big” day and two slow ones. Big meal on Thursday, wineries and a walk on Friday, and a quiet, low‑key Saturday. The pace matters when the days are short.

💡 Good to know: Sunset on Thanksgiving Day in the Hamptons is around 4:30 pm. Plan any beach or lighthouse visits for the earlier half of the day.
Plan Your Thanksgiving on The Hamptons with Us
Thanksgiving in the Hamptons is what the East End looks like at its most authentic: quiet villages, empty beaches, farm‑stand turkeys, and the kind of long, unhurried meals that the holiday is meant for. At Luxury Beach Getaway, we help families plan this weekend every year, from choosing the right property to lining up local recommendations for restaurants, farms, and wineries. If you’re thinking about a Hamptons or North Fork Thanksgiving, get in touch with our team or browse our current availability. We’d love to help you make the most of your holiday on the East End.

Frequently Asked Questions
Where is the best place to have Thanksgiving dinner in the Hamptons?
Baron’s Cove in Sag Harbor, The American Hotel, 1770 House in East Hampton, and Bell & Anchor are all excellent choices for a traditional Thanksgiving dinner out. Reservations open in early October and fill up quickly, so it’s best to book as soon as your plans are set.
Are Hamptons restaurants open on Thanksgiving Day?
Many of the top restaurants in Sag Harbor, East Hampton, and Southampton offer a special Thanksgiving Day menu, though hours vary. Some spots serve a single seating in the early afternoon, while others run dinner service into the evening. Always confirm the seating times when you reserve.
Where can I order a Thanksgiving turkey in the Hamptons?
Round Swamp Farm in East Hampton, Bridgehampton, and Montauk is the best known option, and Iacono Farm in East Hampton is the classic local pick. Both take orders in early November and sell out well before Thanksgiving week.
What is there to do in the Hamptons on Thanksgiving weekend?
Winery tastings on the North Fork, long walks on Cooper’s Beach or Main Beach, holiday shopping in Sag Harbor Village, and a drive out to Montauk Point Lighthouse are all favorites. The Long Island Aquarium in Riverhead is a great rainy‑day option for families.
Is the North Fork worth visiting for Thanksgiving?
Yes. Late November on the North Fork is one of the most underrated times of year. Tasting rooms are open and calm, the farm stands are stocked for the holiday, and the drive along Route 25 through Cutchogue and Peconic is beautiful in the fall light.
When should I book a Hamptons vacation rental for Thanksgiving?
Book at least four to six weeks in advance for a Thanksgiving stay. Waterfront and larger group homes get reserved earliest, and prices are typically much more approachable than the summer season.






























































































































































































































































































