Skip to main content

Vacation Rentals in Laurel, NY

Nestled between Mattituck and Jamesport along the quieter middle stretch of the North Fork, Laurel is the kind of hamlet that rewards people who prefer to discover a place rather than be directed to it. A residential enclave within the Town of Southold, it sits close enough to both the Long Island Sound and Peconic Bay to feel genuinely surrounded by water, without the noise that follows more well-known destinations.

What makes Laurel special is its position. It borrows from everything around it without being defined by any of it. Love Lane in Mattituck is minutes away for coffee, dinner, or a slow browse through independent shops. The wine trail runs right through the surrounding area. Laurel Lake sits tucked in the interior, calm and largely undiscovered by anyone who isn’t local. And Sound Avenue, one of Long Island’s great farm stand roads, connects it all. If you’ve been looking for a North Fork base that feels like a find, Laurel is it.

0 Night
No Properties
When
Guests
Age 13 and above
-
+
Age 2-12
-
+
Bringing a pet?
Filters
-
+
-
+
Types of Place
Features & Amenities

What Guests Are Saying About Their Laurel Stay 

North Fork Oasis: Heated Pool, Hot tub

If my house has a yard like this one, I would never leave home. The heated pool was fantastic in mid-September, as was the hot tub. The house was clean and well-furnished. It had everything we needed for an amazing stay. Also, so much to do on the north fork. We didn’t make it to a vineyard this time, but there were many less than 5 minutes away. We golfed, stopped in Greenport and Southold and Mattituck. Overall, just a really nice relaxing trip. We hope to be back next year!

North Fork Oasis: Heated Pool, Hot tub

We had a great stay at this home. There was plenty of room for our group and the backyard was awesome.

North Fork Oasis: Heated Pool, Hot tub

Great time. Enjoyed the pool, deck, grill and outdoor fireplace. Nice area and close to everything we wanted to visit.

North Fork Oasis: Heated Pool, Hot tub

Nice social house with a large backyard and modern appliances. Walking distance to beach, winery… great for a social gathering, BBQ dinner, hangout by the open fireplace. The basement is equipped with a pool table and the house in general is suitable for groups or families of all ages.

North Fork Oasis: Heated Pool, Hot tub

Wow what a beautiful home, location 10 out of 10, was literally within 5 mins from the vineyards, great restaurants, bagel stores, coffee and directly across the street from the great Peconic bay. So peaceful and serene, with all the best amenities and plenty of space for my entire party! Rain or shine this house is ideal for a group of girls friends, family with children, a couples weekend, it’s an A++ Would love to come back on the summer and be able to enjoy the beautiful pool in the huge backyard. But the hot tub we were able to use and it was perfect and the sleep afterwards divine, like a happy baby

North Fork Oasis: Heated Pool, Hot tub

The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.

    Your Laurel Experience Starts Here

    Between Laurel Lake, the wine trail, Love Lane, and the water on both sides, days here tend to fill up on their own. The North Fork’s best is close in every direction, and Laurel puts you right in the middle of it.

    Laurel Lake

    One of the North Fork’s best-kept freshwater secrets, Laurel Lake sits quietly in the interior of the hamlet and offers a completely different kind of water experience than the bay or Sound. It’s peaceful, scenic, and a welcome change of pace for guests who want to kayak, fish, or simply sit near still water with a book. Early mornings here have a particular quality that’s hard to describe and easy to remember.

    On the Water

    Laurel’s position between the Long Island Sound and Peconic Bay means the water is never far in any direction. Head north for the Sound’s open energy and rocky shoreline, or south toward the bay’s calm shallows, ideal for paddleboarding and clamming. Mattituck Creek, just minutes away, is one of the North Fork’s most scenic inlets and a popular launch point for kayakers. After a full day out, your Luxury Beach Getaway home is exactly the right place to rinse off and settle in for the evening.

    The Wine Trail

    Laurel sits in the heart of North Fork wine country with exceptional access to tasting rooms in every direction. Shinn Estate Vineyards is right in the hamlet itself, one of the most respected producers on the entire trail. Bedell Cellars and Pellegrini Vineyards are just minutes east in Cutchogue, and the trail continues in both directions from there. Spend an afternoon working your way through tasting rooms, or pick one vineyard, find a spot on the lawn, and treat it as a destination rather than a stop. Either way, bring something back to your Luxury Beach Getaway home for the evening.

    Love Lane and Mattituck

    Just minutes from Laurel, Mattituck’s Love Lane is one of the North Fork’s most charming small-town streets and well worth building a morning or evening around. Independent coffee shops, wine and cheese spots, and a handful of excellent restaurants make it the kind of place you end up returning to more than once during a stay. It rounds out the quieter pace of Laurel perfectly without ever feeling like too much.

      Frequently Asked Questions

      Where exactly is Laurel on the North Fork?

      Laurel is a hamlet within the Town of Southold, situated between Mattituck to the west and Jamesport to the east. It sits roughly in the center of the North Fork’s length, within easy driving distance of nearly every town from Riverhead to Greenport, and close to both the Long Island Sound and Peconic Bay.

      How do I get to Laurel from New York City?

      By car, plan for roughly two hours from Midtown Manhattan depending on traffic. The Long Island Rail Road serves Mattituck, just minutes from Laurel, making a car-free trip genuinely workable. Seasonal jitney service also connects to various North Fork stops throughout the summer.

      Are the homes suitable for families and groups? 

      Very much so. The combination of calm bay waters, Laurel Lake, and the unhurried pace of the hamlet makes it an excellent choice for families with children of any age. Our homes here are spacious, well-equipped, and suited to the kind of relaxed, low-key week that families come back to year after year.

      What should we do on a first visit to Laurel?

      Start with coffee on Love Lane in Mattituck, then explore Laurel Lake by kayak or take a morning walk to the Sound. Spend the afternoon at Shinn Estate or one of the nearby tasting rooms, pick up provisions from a farm stand on Sound Avenue, and cook dinner back at the house. That first day sets the tone for everything that follows.