Places to eat

Wading River Pizzeria

Neighborhood pizzeria in Wading River serving specialty thin-crust slices, pasta classics, and cozy takeout in a casual, family-friendly setting.

Wading River Pizzeria is a longtime local favorite offering a wide variety of specialty slices—from Grandma pies to penne alla vodka—plus classic Italian entrées and pasta dishes. Patrons highlight their crispy, well-crafted crust and generous toppings. The penne alla vodka, ravioli, and clam sauce are frequently praised for quality beyond takeout review expectations. Despite variable reviews on service or oven consistency, many diners regard it as the best pizza in the area. One fan described it as having the “premier pizza joints with wonderful selection of Italian food and various pizza styles,” and another called the lunch specials and sauce “mind-blowing.” Whether you’re picking up a spin on classic slices or a hearty pasta lunch special, Wading River Pizzeria delivers casual charm and dependable flavor from a bright, clean setting.

Have your dinner in and spend the night relaxing in one of our Wading River getaways within a few minutes’ drive:

After Dune Delight – Just steps from the beach, this coastal home is perfect for-paced evenings after dinner.
Artist’s Nature Retreat – A tranquil sanctuary with natural surroundings and shoreline access.
Beachfront Romance – Rustic waterfront cottage with private beach access, ideal for quiet family moments.
Coastal Retreat – Waterside home featuring a panoramic deck overlooking serene bay views.
Sea Cliff Charm – Cozy waterfront layout with firepit and easy beach access for evening relaxation.