Blue Water Fish

Blue Water Fish is a family-run seafood market and take-out destination founded by Tom Infantolino, offering the freshest catch right from the docks. Tom’s philosophy is simple: “I won’t sell anything I wouldn’t eat myself”—a promise reflected in their daily rotated selection of locally sourced fluke, striped bass, clams, scallops, shrimp, swordfish, and live lobsters. The menu delights seafood lovers with classics like New England and Manhattan clam chowders, lobster bisque, fish & chips, lobster rolls, shrimp salad sandwiches, and more. Prepared meals include lobster mac & cheese, stuffed sole, and crispy fried boats loaded with shrimp, scallops, or fish—easy to enjoy on the go or by the water. With a stellar 4.6 rating across local reviewers and consistent praise for quality, freshness, and welcoming service, Blue Water Fish is a can’t-miss stop for seafood lovers on the North Fork.

Head back to your waterfront haven after picking up your seafood feast at Blue Water Fish. These Wading River–based properties offer elegant coastal retreats with family-friendly luxury:

• After Dune Delight – Just steps from the beach, ideal for sunset strolls with seafood in hand.

• Artist’s Nature Retreat – A peaceful sanctuary surrounded by nature and shoreline.

• Beachfront Romance – Rustic desert charm with private beachfront access for relaxed evenings.

• Coastal Retreat – Waterfront home featuring a panoramic deck overlooking tranquil bay waters.

• Sea Cliff Charm – Classic Wading River home with firepit, near beach access for cozy nights.

By pairing Blue Water Fish with one of these charming Wading River homes, you’ll enjoy unmatched seafood paired with serene coastal luxury.